The 2026 read, in one paragraph
Appreciation through the full cycle (FHFA)
Most “South Florida is up X%” numbers quote the last decade and stop. The honest version includes the crash, because it’s the single biggest risk in the data.
| Metro division (FHFA) | 5-year | 10-year | 20-year | 2006 peak → trough |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| West Palm Beach–Boca Raton–Delray Beach | +71.6% | +142.4% | +89.5% | −49.4% |
| Fort Lauderdale–Pompano Beach–Sunrise | +57.7% | +121.5% | +72.1% | −48% |
Two lessons an investor should actually act on:
- The 10-year number is real, but it’s a recovery number. A large slice of that +142.4% is the market climbing back out of a ~49.4% hole. Buying at the top of a cycle and riding it down for years is a very different experience from the headline.
- The 20-year number is closer to the true long-run trend because it includes both the crash and the recovery. Anchor expectations there, not on the post-2012 rocket.
The rent floor (HUD FY2026)
HUD publishes fair-market rents by ZIP and bedroom count. They’re not live-market rents — they lag and they’re conservative — which is exactly why they work as a floor when you stress-test a deal. Across 276 South Florida ZIP codes, a 2-bedroom ranges $1,050–$3,650/mo, median ~$2,440. The spread is the story: coastal and inland 2BRs can differ by 3×. “The South Florida rent” is not a number — it’s a ZIP-level question. See rents by city and ZIP.
What rate cycles have meant here (the honest caveat)
The public record shows the intuitive pattern — lower financing costs tend to support demand and prices — but with a caveat too big to ignore: there are very few clean episodes, and the two biggest (2008 and 2020) were dominated by a financial crisis and a pandemic, not rates alone. Lower rates cut both ways for a rental investor: they can lift the price you pay and your tenant pool’s rent-vs-buy math. The net effect on your cash-on-cash depends on your entry price, not the headline rate. This is context, not a prediction.
How to underwrite in a market like this
The through-line of all three datasets: the deal is made or lost on the numbers you run before you buy, not on the trend line behind you. In South Florida specifically, the line items that most often break a deal are the ones the MLS calculator skips:
- The year-1 tax reset. Florida reassesses at just value the January 1 after a sale, so the seller’s capped tax bill doesn’t transfer — often understating year-1 cost by 2–3×.
- Insurance. The most expensive market in the country, and it isn’t a field in the MLS.
- HOA + special assessments. Post-Surfside, five-figure assessments are surfacing across South Florida condos, usually disclosed as one sentence in the remarks.
That’s the work ReSharpe automates: it turns the live MLS feed into cap rate, cash flow and the buyer’s true monthly payment — tax reset, insurance and HOA included — calibrated on real nearby closed leases, for licensed Palm Beach / Broward / St. Lucie and Miami-Dade agents. The approach is on the methodology page.
Data sources: FHFA All-Transactions House Price Index via FRED (St. Louis Fed) (2026-06-11) · FHFA HPI · HUD Small Area Fair Market Rents FY2026 (2026-06-11) · HUD User. Educational context for licensed professionals and investors — not investment, tax or legal advice, and not a prediction of future prices.
Frequently asked questions
- How much have South Florida home prices appreciated?
- Per the FHFA House Price Index, the West Palm Beach–Boca Raton–Delray Beach metro is up about 142.4% over 10 years and 89.5% over 20; Fort Lauderdale–Pompano–Sunrise is up about 121.5% over 10 years. Both fell roughly 49.4% peak-to-trough after 2006, so the trend is cyclical, not a straight line.
- What is a typical rent in South Florida?
- By HUD's FY2026 Small Area Fair Market Rents, a 2-bedroom across South Florida ZIP codes runs about $1,050–$3,650 per month (median around $2,440). That's a conservative government benchmark, useful as a floor when you stress-test a deal, not live-market lease data.
- Do falling interest rates mean it's a good time to buy in South Florida?
- There are very few clean historical episodes to learn from, and the biggest (2008, 2020) were dominated by a crisis and a pandemic, not rates alone. Lower rates can lift both the price you pay and your tenant pool's rent-vs-buy math, so the net effect on your cash-on-cash depends on your entry price. Treat rate forecasts as context, not a prediction, and underwrite each deal on its own numbers.
Underwrite South Florida deals on the real numbers.
For licensed agents & brokers. Start a 7-day free trial — no charge until we activate you.